top of page

The Business Owner's Year-End Payroll Checklist: What to Review Before 2027

Writer: Michael Burk
Michael Burk
1 minute ago
7 min read
Bookkeeping made easy with MCB Consulting Group.
Contact MCB Consulting Group to learn more!

Year-end payroll responsibilities involve more than issuing employee paychecks and preparing W-2 forms. 


For business owners with employees or independent contractors, the final weeks of the year are an important time to review payroll records, reconcile wages, verify tax payments, and prepare for required reporting.


Payroll errors can lead to incorrect tax filings, reporting delays, and unnecessary administrative work.



Taking time to review your records before the end of December can help identify discrepancies while there is still time to address them.


Whether you manage payroll internally or work with an outside payroll provider, having accurate and organized records is essential.


Here are seven important areas every employer should review before closing out 2026.


1. Review Employee Records and Payroll Information


Start by reviewing your employee records to make sure the information used for payroll and year-end reporting is accurate.


Even small discrepancies, such as an incorrect Social Security number or outdated mailing address, can create problems when preparing employee tax documents.


Review the following information for each employee:


  • Full legal name and Social Security number.

  • Current mailing address.

  • Employment and termination dates.

  • Current Form W-4 withholding information.

  • Compensation and pay rate information.

  • Employee benefits and deductions.

  • Paid time off and applicable leave records.

  • Any changes in employment status during the year.


If employees have changed addresses, names, or withholding elections, make sure those updates have been properly reflected in your payroll system.


It is also a good opportunity to review your employee files and confirm that required documentation is complete and securely maintained.


Why this matters: Accurate employee information helps prevent incorrect W-2 reporting, returned tax documents, and delays in year-end payroll processing.


2. Reconcile Year-to-Date Payroll Records


One of the most important steps in year-end payroll preparation is reconciling your payroll records.


Throughout the year, employers process payroll, withhold taxes, make tax deposits, and file quarterly employment tax returns. Before preparing annual employee tax documents, these records should be reviewed against one another.


Start by comparing your payroll reports with:


  • Year-to-date employee wage summaries.

  • Quarterly federal payroll tax returns (Form 941, when applicable).

  • Federal payroll tax deposit records.

  • State and local payroll tax filings.

  • Employer Social Security and Medicare contributions.

  • Employee federal, state, and local tax withholdings.


Look for differences between the amounts recorded in your payroll system and the amounts reported or deposited.


For example, if your payroll records show one amount for federal income tax withholding but your quarterly filings show another, investigate the discrepancy before preparing W-2 forms.


Also, review any payroll adjustments, voided checks, off-cycle payments, or corrections made throughout the year.


Reconciliation helps ensure that annual wage reporting is consistent with the payroll activity already reported to government agencies.


3. Review Wages, Bonuses, Commissions, and Other Compensation


Employee compensation is not always limited to regular hourly wages or salaries.

Before closing out the year, review all forms of compensation paid during 2026 to make sure they have been properly recorded and classified.


This may include:


  • Regular employee wages and salaries.

  • Overtime payments.

  • Bonuses and performance incentives.

  • Sales commissions.

  • Reported tips.

  • Taxable fringe benefits.

  • Certain employer-provided benefits.

  • Other supplemental compensation.


If your business offers year-end bonuses or commissions, make sure those payments are included in the appropriate payroll period and reported correctly.


Special attention should also be given to taxable benefits and noncash compensation. Certain benefits may need to be included in an employee's taxable wages even though they were not paid directly as cash.


For 2026, employers should also confirm that their payroll systems are capturing applicable reporting requirements for qualified overtime compensation and reported tips under the updated federal tax rules.


If you are considering year-end bonuses or additional compensation, discuss the payroll and tax implications with your payroll provider or tax professional before processing payments.


Recent tax law changes introduced new federal income tax deductions for qualifying tips and overtime pay, beginning with the 2025 tax year.


Eligible workers may qualify for deductions of up to $25,000 for tips and $12,500 for overtime compensation, subject to income limits and other requirements.


What does this mean for employees and employers? Not all tips and overtime qualify. Occupation, compensation, eligibility requirements, and proper payroll reporting all matter.

Infographic with lightbulb and text: Did you know. No tax on tips and overtime, with money jar, clock, and briefcase icons.

Employers should also ensure qualifying tips and overtime are properly tracked and reported on employee W-2 forms.

Have questions about how these changes affect you or your business? Contact MCB Consulting Group. We can help you understand what you need to know before filing.



4. Verify Payroll Tax Deposits and Reporting Responsibilities


Employers are responsible for withholding and depositing applicable payroll taxes, including federal income tax, Social Security, and Medicare taxes.


Depending on the business and its payroll tax liability, federal tax deposits may be required monthly or semiweekly.


Before the year closes, review your deposit history to confirm that required payments were made accurately and on time.


Pay attention to:


  • Federal income tax withheld from employee wages.

  • Employee Social Security and Medicare contributions.

  • Employer Social Security and Medicare contributions.

  • Federal unemployment tax (FUTA).

  • State unemployment insurance contributions.

  • State and local payroll tax obligations.


Federal employment tax deposits generally must be made electronically. Employers should confirm their required deposit schedule rather than assuming all payroll taxes are due at the same time.


Also, review quarterly Form 941 filings and confirm that any outstanding payroll tax liabilities have been addressed.


Important: Filing a quarterly payroll tax return and depositing payroll taxes are separate responsibilities. Completing one does not automatically satisfy the other.

If you use an outside payroll service, verify which responsibilities the provider handles and which remain your responsibility as the employer.


5. Review Employee Withholding and Payroll Deductions


Employee withholding and deductions can change throughout the year. Before preparing annual wage statements, review payroll records to make sure the amounts are accurate.

Start with federal Form W-4 information and confirm that employee withholding elections have been properly reflected in payroll calculations.


Review other applicable deductions and contributions, including:


  • Health insurance premiums.

  • Retirement plan contributions.

  • Health savings account contributions, when applicable.

  • Flexible spending account contributions.

  • Employee benefit deductions.

  • Wage garnishments and other authorized deductions.


Make sure deductions are classified correctly and that employee and employer contributions are properly recorded.


You should also remind employees to review their withholding elections and submit updated Forms W-4 if their circumstances have changed.


Remember that an employee's withholding election affects the amount deducted from their paycheck. It does not necessarily determine the employee's final tax liability.


Accurate payroll records help employees receive correct wage statements and help employers prepare their annual reporting.


6. Organize Independent Contractor Payment Records


If your business works with independent contractors, freelancers, consultants, or other outside service providers, year-end is the time to review those payments as well.


Start by reviewing your vendor and contractor records to make sure payments have been properly classified and documented.


Gather the following information:


  • Contractor's legal name and business information.

  • Completed Form W-9, when required.

  • Taxpayer identification number.

  • Mailing address.

  • Total payments made during 2026.

  • Dates and descriptions of services provided.

  • Payment method and supporting documentation.


Review payments made by check, electronic transfer, and other payment methods. Also consider whether payments processed through third-party settlement organizations are subject to separate reporting requirements.


For 2026 payments, the general federal Form 1099-NEC reporting threshold for qualifying nonemployee compensation has increased from $600 to $2,000.


This change is important for businesses that regularly hire contractors or freelancers. However, certain reporting requirements still apply regardless of the payment amount, including applicable backup withholding situations.


It is also important to distinguish between an independent contractor and an employee. The classification depends on the actual working relationship, not simply the agreement or payment method used.


If you are uncertain about how someone should be classified, discuss the situation with a qualified tax professional before preparing year-end forms.


7. Prepare for W-2 and 1099 Reporting


Once employee payroll and contractor payment records have been reviewed and reconciled, the next step is preparing required year-end tax documents.

For most employers, this includes Forms W-2 for employees and Forms 1099-NEC for qualifying independent contractors.


W-2 Reporting


Employers generally must prepare a Form W-2 for each employee who meets the applicable reporting requirements.


The form reports information such as:


  • Annual wages and compensation.

  • Federal income tax withheld.

  • Social Security wages and taxes.

  • Medicare wages and taxes.

  • Applicable tips and other reportable compensation.

  • Certain retirement and benefit contributions.


Employers must provide employees with their W-2 forms and file the required copies with the Social Security Administration.


1099-NEC Reporting

Businesses generally use Form 1099-NEC to report qualifying payments made to independent contractors and other nonemployees for services performed in the course of business.

Make sure contractor information is accurate and payment totals have been reviewed before preparing the forms.


Important 2027 Deadline

For 2026 calendar-year reporting, the general federal deadline for furnishing W-2 forms to employees and filing them with the Social Security Administration is February 1, 2027.


The same general February 1, 2027 deadline applies to furnishing and filing qualifying Forms 1099-NEC for 2026 payments.


January 31, 2027 falls on a Sunday, which moves the applicable deadline to the following business day.


Do not wait until the end of January to begin this process. Allow time to correct missing information, resolve discrepancies, and prepare the required forms.


A Final Year-End Payroll Review Can Make a Difference

Payroll is one of the most important administrative responsibilities for a business with employees or independent contractors.


Taking time to review employee information, reconcile payroll records, verify tax deposits, and organize contractor payments can help prevent unnecessary complications as the new year begins.


It is also an opportunity to evaluate your existing payroll processes. Are records being maintained consistently? Are tax payments being made on schedule? Are employee and contractor records easy to access? Are you confident that your payroll reporting is accurate?

If these processes have become difficult to manage, it may be time to consider additional support.

 

Let MCB Consulting Group Help You Stay Organized


At MCB Consulting Group, we understand that managing a business involves more than serving customers and generating revenue. Keeping financial records organized, managing payroll responsibilities, and maintaining accurate bookkeeping all play an important role in running a successful operation.


Our bookkeeping, payroll, cash flow management, and business financial services help business owners stay on top of important financial responsibilities.

Whether you need help organizing your records, improving your bookkeeping processes, or managing ongoing payroll responsibilities, having the right support can make a meaningful difference.


Don't let year-end payroll responsibilities become a January headache. Start reviewing your records now and enter 2027 with greater confidence.


Contact MCB Consulting Group to learn how we can help your business stay organized and prepared. Contact us for more information and to set you up for success in 2026.

Subscribe to our website • Don’t miss out on the latest blog posts and updates!

Thanks for subscribing!

© 2026 MCB Consulting Group

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page